Edinburgh councillors have backed a motion to investigate a 'loophole' that allows short-term let operators to obtain licences without ever securing planning consent.
The Loophole
The issue centres on a disconnect between the licensing and planning systems. Under current rules, prospective STL operators only need to say they are in the process of obtaining planning permission in order to apply for a licence.
Once the licence is granted, some operators have been withdrawing their planning applications - effectively operating with a licence but without the planning consent that Edinburgh's Short-Term Let Control Area is supposed to require.
Green councillor Chas Booth, who brought the motion, described the situation as making a "mockery" of Edinburgh's commitment to use homes for people and not for profit.
What's Happening
Councillors backed the motion with amendments. The agreed actions are:
- Council officers to bring a report to the Planning Committee discussing the issue
- The council's chief executive to write to the Scottish Government asking for the legislative gap to be closed
- A workshop for officers and councillors to discuss enforcement options
What This Means for Operators
This development signals a potential tightening of the rules around the licensing-planning interaction. If the Scottish Government acts on Edinburgh's request, operators may face stricter requirements to demonstrate genuine planning consent.
Operators with established use should consider applying for a Certificate of Lawfulness (CLUD) to formally confirm their lawful status - this provides the strongest legal protection regardless of how the rules evolve.
New operators should ensure they have a genuine planning strategy in place before applying for a licence. Contact us for advice on the best approach for your specific situation.
Need expert help with your STL?
Whether it's licensing, planning permission, or compliance - our team can help you navigate the complexity.
Book Free Consultation